Now Playing

Alicia Keys

If I Ain't Got You

Labour's Climate Claims Under Fire in Reading

The ruling Labour Party have been accused of "fiddling with numbers while Reading burns."

Reading Borough Council declared a climate emergency in 2019, pledging to be net-zero by 2030. Its strategic environment, planning and transport committee gets an annual progress report.

Ben Burfoot, the council's sustainability manager, highlighted cuts in gas use (64.6%) and oil and fuel (61.6%) since the 2008/09 baseline.

But Green councillor Dave McElroy rubbished the positive outlook.

"This is my fifth year receiving this report and the pattern is familiar. The headlines remain positive, but the trajectory beneath them becomes more concerning.

"The easy wins have largely been taken. The council's own report acknowledges that emissions reductions have plateaued and that targets are getting missed.

"The report relies on funding bids and schemes that may or may not happen to remain positive."

Cllr McElroy (Green, Redlands) said the report failed to take into account national decarbonisation and the effects of austerity, arguing service cuts had been repackaged as decarbonisation.

"In many cases the emissions have not disappeared, they have simply moved outside the council's preferred reporting boundary.

"That is particularly relevant when the council claims to be 'leading by example'.

"The flagship figure excludes many activities over which the council still has direct influence, including schools, and leisure centres. Things the report says are not doing as well.

"The borough cannot outsource itself. It is getting bigger, not smaller. It is no wonder it is falling behind when the council chooses to exclude the inconvenient parts from its headline success story, something the borough cannot do."

He went on to argue the government is making achieving the target more difficult by cutting at least £1 billion from the Warm Homes Plan, freezing fuel duty and 'slashing' electric vehicle (EV) targets.

"In this context, Reading's climate strategy looks less like a story of accelerating progress and more like a story of missed targets wrapped in good news headlines.

"It looks like this Labour council has effectively abandoned its 2030 ambitions and are just keeping up the pretence for as long as they can get away with it.

"Fiddling with numbers while Reading burns."

Immediately after that, cllr Will Cross (Labour, Redlands), the chair, quipped: "Can I just say, it makes a welcome change for the Green Party to be talking about climate, for once."

Mr Burfoot did acknowledge that academisation has reduced the council's ability to impose efficiency measures on schools. He pointed to the council's new build housing programme as an 'excellent example' of what can be done.

Heat pumps were installed for the 37 flats in North Street and the 15 key worker flats at Arthur Hill.

Clapping back, John Ennis (Labour, Southcote), lead councillor for climate strategy, said: "After cllr McElroy's madcap manifesto, I thought he had disappeared, but he's back now!"

The exchanges took place on Thursday, November 12.

James Aldridge, Local Democracy Reporter

On Air Now

VIP Club

Sign up to get more with the Listener Club!

Get Our Apps

  • Available on the App Store
  • Available on Google Play
  • Just ask Amazon Alexa